The Best Nutritionists and Dietitians in New York, NY (2026)
Many nutritionists and dietitians in New York list the same specialties, so the useful differences are the credential, whether you meet in person or online, and how many people have rated them. On Google, the top-ranked practice holds 4.9 stars from 171 reviews, and every practice here has at least 40.
Short answer
Compass Nutrition leads with 4.9 stars from 171 Google reviews, and its website describes virtual counseling with registered dietitians. Nutritionist NYC follows with 5 stars from 129 Google reviews and weekday hours until 8 PM. Amy Stephens, MS, RDN, CSSD CEDS has 5 stars from 40 Google reviews and describes a focus on sports nutrition.
New York Practices, Compared on One Page
| # | Name | Rating | Reviews | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Compass Nutrition | 4.9 | 171 | Largest review history |
| #2 | Nutritionist NYC | 5.0 | 129 | Weekday hours until 8 PM |
| #3 | New York City Nutrition | 5.0 | 91 | Gut and hormone topics |
| #4 | Farnaz Fahimirad, RD | 5.0 | 45 | Open seven days |
| #5 | Amy Stephens, MS, RDN, CSSD CEDS | 5.0 | 40 | Sports nutrition focus |
Ratings and review counts from Google, checked Oct 2026.
Who Each Practice Is and Who It Suits
- Address 90 Broad St, New York, NY 10004
- Hours Mon to Wed: 8:00 AM to 8:30 PM · Thu: 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM · Fri: 9:00 AM to 1:00 PM
As listed on Google, checked Oct 2026
Compass Nutrition is a nutrition counseling practice at 90 Broad St. Its website says it offers virtual counseling with registered dietitians for weight management, GLP-1 medication support, digestive health and food sensitivities, and that it accepts many major insurance plans, subject to coverage and eligibility.
What people praise
- Feeling heard and listened to in a first consultation, which one reviewer says lasted an hour
- Quick replies to emails and calls that explain the plan
- One reviewer found the intake forms thorough
- Having the science of digestion and food explained
Worth knowing
- Open Monday to Friday, with Friday 9 AM to 1 PM
Reputation scorecard
Volume ranked among 13 New York listings
Our take: A good first call for anyone who wants virtual counseling for digestive health, food sensitivities or weight management, and a first consultation where they feel heard.
- Address 1133 Broadway Ste 1021, New York, NY 10010
- Hours Mon to Fri: 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM
As listed on Google, checked Oct 2026
Nutritionist NYC is a nutrition counseling practice at 1133 Broadway, Suite 1021, open 8 AM to 8 PM Monday to Friday. It offers functional nutrition counseling through telehealth, with specialties such as diabetes, gut health, PCOS, prenatal and postpartum care, sports nutrition and eating disorders. Its website says you are matched with a registered dietitian. The site also has membership and weight management pages and a free grocery guide.
What people praise
- Approachable, supportive practitioners who are good listeners and offer options that fit into daily life
- Explanations that are clear without feeling overwhelming
- Plans built around a work schedule and daily routine
- Practical tips along the way
Reputation scorecard
Volume ranked among 13 New York listings
Our take: Suits someone who wants weekday appointments until 8 PM, or a plan built around a busy work schedule.
- Address 244 5th Ave, New York, NY 10001
- Hours Tue to Thu: 9:00 AM to 8:00 PM · Fri: 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
As listed on Google, checked Oct 2026
New York City Nutrition is at 244 5th Ave. It offers nutrition coaching and personal training, with gut health, hormone health, longevity and sports nutrition among its topics, and also mentions PCOS, menopause support and corporate wellness. Reviewers mention working with it by telehealth, including from New Jersey.
What people praise
- Practitioners who explain the reasons behind their recommendations
- Staff described as supportive and responsive
- Being listened to without judgment
- Telehealth is mentioned as convenient for people outside the city
Worth knowing
- Open Tuesday to Friday only, closed Monday and the weekend
Reputation scorecard
Volume ranked among 13 New York listings
Our take: A fit if you want a team that offers telehealth and covers several topics in one place.
- Address 6 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017
- Hours Mon to Sun: 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM
As listed on Google, checked Oct 2026
Farnaz Fahimirad, RD works online through Fay, a national telehealth company, with an address at 6 E 45th St, and is open 7 AM to 9 PM every day. Her Fay profile lists the credentials MS, RDN, CDN and CLC and describes her as a clinical dietitian and certified lactation consultant. She offers video calls and in-person visits, with diabetes, IBS, PCOS, bariatric care, sports nutrition and vegan and vegetarian eating as specialties.
What people praise
- She takes time in every session
- Practical, clear recommendations, with sessions that also cover stress and mental clarity according to one reviewer
- Feeling supported when sharing goals
- One reviewer mentions a useful way to stay accountable
Worth knowing
- Booking and insurance estimates run through Fay
Reputation scorecard
Volume ranked among 13 New York listings
Our take: A strong choice if you want a single named dietitian with weekend availability.
- Address 39 1/2 Washington Square S Ste 1w, New York, NY 10012
As listed on Google, checked Oct 2026
Amy Stephens, MS, RDN, CSSD CEDS is a dietitian at Washington Square South who specializes in sports nutrition and eating disorders. She sees clients virtually and in person, works with athletes from many sports, especially distance runners and endurance athletes, and takes bookings through her website. Her website says she is a licensed dietitian and a board certified sports dietetics specialist with more than 25 years of experience.
What people praise
- A warm, non-judgmental manner
- One reviewer says she checks first whether it is comfortable to discuss weight and calories
- A group talk for a run club is described as clear and engaging
- Easy-to-follow individual plans
Reputation scorecard
Volume ranked among 13 New York listings
Our take: Best for athletes and runners, or for anyone who wants a dietitian with a focus on sports nutrition and eating disorders.
Where the Order Comes From
Google's numbers only
Ratings and review counts are Google's, read in October 2026, and we never edit them.
Right kind, right place
Each practice carries Google's own nutritionist or dietitian category, has an address in New York and is rated 4.0 or higher. One company appears once.
History counts for more
The order weighs the rating by how many people gave it, so a large review history counts for more than a perfect score from a handful.
What each scorecard shows
Rating, size of the review history, the share of four and five star ratings, and whether Google lists a website, phone and hours.
Check the license
Registered dietitian (RD or RDN) is a national credential that a person has to earn and keep. The word nutritionist is used more loosely, and the rules for it differ from state to state. Before you book, ask which credential the person holds and where you can look it up, and ask whether they are licensed in New York.
Questions for Your First Call
- Which credential does the practitioner hold, and what is their New York license?
- Are sessions in person, online or both?
- Is my insurance accepted, and what does a session cost in total?
- How many sessions are typical for what I need?
- Will you share notes with my doctor?
- What happens if I need to reschedule or stop?
More Reviews
Frequently Asked Questions
Which practice has the most Google reviews?
Compass Nutrition, with 171 reviews and a 4.9 rating.
Which practice works through Fay?
Farnaz Fahimirad, RD works online through Fay, a national telehealth company, and her Fay profile also lists in-person visits.
Which one lists a sports nutrition focus?
Amy Stephens, MS, RDN, CSSD CEDS. Her website describes a licensed dietitian specializing in sports nutrition and eating disorders.
Our Short Version
Compass Nutrition is the safe default on the numbers, with the largest review history. Amy Stephens, MS, RDN, CSSD CEDS suits athletes, and Farnaz Fahimirad, RD suits anyone who prefers booking through Fay. This page is not medical advice, and your doctor's view comes first, so call and ask the questions above before you book.